 |
4. Water
and Agriculture
First of all it is necessary to address the question of irrigated
agriculture in the entire region as this is overwhelmingly the
largest water user.
4.1. Importance of Agriculture in the
economy
Certain sectors of the economies of the Palestinian Authority
Areas, Israel and Jordan have already demonstrated that water
resource-deficient regions can generate livelihoods and initiate
development beyond that which stems from traditional rural activities.
In Israel, agriculture accounts for only 3% of the GDP, yet
water is still allocated in abundance for irrigation. Water
is more than a simple liquid; in some circumstances it is also
an economic good and as such it can be traded and substituted.
Water can be made available to arid regions through the importation
of agricultural products, and in particular food, far cheaper
and with less hazardous consequences to the environment than
attempts to produce the population's food requirements locally.
This also frees large amounts of water for domestic, environmental
and, once these needs are met, industrial and developmental activities.
Water can be used far more efficiently, in terms of both income
generation and employment opportunities, in business, services,
tourism or manufacturing, thus increasing the nation's GDP and
therefore the funds which they will need to purchase food via
international markets. With greater economic productivity, a
state can achieve total self-reliance and food security, which
is more reliable and sustainable in an arid zone than attempts
to achieve food self-sufficiency. All such major adjustments
in a society must be accompanied by awareness raising and education
programmes; no change will be sustainable if it out-runs a community's
capacity to adapt to new circumstances.
4.2. Toward Regional Food Security
Urgent solutions are required, and any solution will
necessarily involve a variety of measures as well as a drastic
reappraisal of current agricultural practices. Many states in
arid regions have already "run-out" of water in terms
of being anywhere close to the ability to claim self-sufficiency
in food production. Yet the ideal of self-sufficiency has so
long been connected with state-security and independence that
authorities are loath to admit this, thinking it would be "political
suicide" and weaken their position in relation to other
states. This is a paradigm which should be encouraged to shift
if the political, social and environmental consequences of water
scarcity are to be averted. The alternative, and preferable
policy choice is that of food security. This option was long
ago adopted by states such as Japan, Singapore and Malta, resulting
in massive increases in the development and wealth of the countries
as there are much "higher returns" to water in service
and industrial sectors than in agriculture. In the Jordan Valley,
the regional food security should be actively sought.
4.3. Virtual Water
The water embedded in food traded on international markets
is know as "virtual water". The virtual water paradigm
has been presented as a solution to the problem of balancing
economic and population growth, ecological sustainability and
the provision of an acceptable standard of living for all people.
Importing virtual water is a way of achieving an equilibrium
and therefore reconciling the sustainable development debate
in the Middle East without curbing economic growth in the region.
Food security and adequate supplies of water for domestic, industrial
and certain agricultural needs can coexist under this new paradigm.
Virtual water manages to reallocate the spatially unequal distribution
of water resources by harnessing global soil water, mostly from
temperate zones, for the benefit of all regions. There is almost
no naturally occurring soil water in this part of the Middle
East, which makes the use of natural surface and underground
waters for irrigation an extremely expensive practice. Expensive
in the sense that agriculture is not an efficient method of transforming
scarce water resources into economic gains; expensive when considering
that this water is currently being taken at a rate beyond that
which can be naturally replenished; and, most of all, expensive
in a region where not all people have access to clean water for
drinking and sanitation.
4.4. Agricultural Biotechnology
In mid and long-term, agricultural biotechnology can
also help to relieving the water crisis. The Jordan Valley farmers
could produce more by, for example, developing new crop varieties
that are drought-tolerant, resistant to insects and weeds, resistant
to a certain level of salinity, and able to capture nitrogen
from the air. Biotech can also make the foods farmers produce
more nutritious by increasing the Vitamin A, iron and other nutrients
in the edible portion of the plant. Modern biotechnology research,
together with appropriate policies, better infrastructure and
traditional research methods already developed in Israel in full
cooperation with fellow riparian countries can bring benefits
to farmers and consumers in the whole region. Governments must
invest in biotech. research to help farmers, and the public and
private sectors must work as partners.
4.5. Decision Making Support Models
Water is essential to life, development and the environment,
and the three must be managed together, not sequentially. Research,
public education and the management of watersheds and river basins
by local communities can make this possible. Each water community,
as part of the water planning process, should consider how much
water to allocate to the natural environment that provides them
with water for life. Decision-support models are available for
this, in the form of the Water Allocation and Management Planning
process, and experience using them should be observed carefully
for their efficacy and with a view to applying the lessons learned
elsewhere. International and national legislation should require
this, as it does already in Australia and South Africa and should
be developed in Middle East to assist the decision-makers to
make the right choice.
4.6. Package of Solutions
The shift away from attempts at food self-sufficiency
to a policy of self-reliance and food security, heavily inter-linked
with the progress towards greater regional security, must also
be complemented by other measures. There is no miracle cure
to the region's water shortage, but a package of solutions including:
improved agricultural efficiency "more crops per drop",
the Blue Revolution, improved water efficiency "more jobs
per drop", better distribution to reduce losses, greater
public awareness and participation, a commitment to water equity
and rights, information sharing, and the development of new water
supplies through re-use, recycling and desalination. All involve
an important value and perception change, from seeing water as
a commodity to be exploited, often at the expense of one's neighbours
and the environment, and a source of conflict, to seeing the
region's water as a shared and fragile resource to be used for
the benefit of all peoples and as an avenue towards greater cooperation
and trust in the region.
|